Bear Lake Fishing

Bear Lake Fishing: A Complete Guide to Utah and Idaho’s High-Altitude Angler’s Paradise

Set against a backdrop of turquoise waters and snow-dusted mountains, Bear Lake—straddling the border between Utah and Idaho—offers more than just beach lounging and scenic drives. It’s also a renowned fishing destination, famous for its rare native fish species, clean waters, and year-round angling opportunities.

Whether you're casting from the shore, trolling by boat, or dropping a line through a frozen surface in winter, Bear Lake has something for every angler. In this guide, we’ll explore the species you can catch, the best fishing spots, licensing requirements, seasonal tips, and local traditions that make Bear Lake fishing an unforgettable experience.

What Makes Bear Lake Unique for Fishing?

What truly sets Bear Lake apart is its native fish population, especially the Bonneville Cisco and Bear Lake Whitefish—species found only in this lake. It’s also one of the few places in the U.S. where you can catch lake trout, cutthroat trout, and whitefish all in one trip.

Add to that its clean, cold, and deep waters (over 200 feet in places) and a surface area of more than 112 square miles, and it’s no wonder Bear Lake has earned a reputation as a premier fishing destination in the Rocky Mountain region.

Popular Fish Species in Bear Lake

Bonneville Cisco – A small, schooling fish endemic to Bear Lake. Most active in January.

Bear Lake Whitefish – A deep-water species, also endemic to the lake, known for its fine flavor.

Bonneville Whitefish – Larger than the Bear Lake variety; found near rocky shorelines.

Lake Trout (Mackinaw) – Can exceed 30 pounds; found in deep waters year-round.

Cutthroat Trout – Bear Lake supports a native population of Bonneville cutthroat trout.

Yellow Perch – Common near weed beds and shallower areas, popular with casual anglers.

Best Times of Year to Fish Bear Lake

Year-round fishing is possible at Bear Lake, but the experience varies by season:

Winter (January–March):

◉ Ice fishing is hugely popular.

◉ Best time to catch Cisco (especially mid-January during spawning).

◉ Target whitefish and cutthroat trout through the ice.

Spring (April–June):

◉ Warmer temps trigger lake trout activity.

◉ Shore fishing near inlets becomes productive.

Summer (July–August):

◉ Early mornings and late evenings are best due to heat.

◉ Boat fishing and trolling are productive methods for trout.

Fall (September–November):

◉ Fish become more active again as temperatures drop.

◉ Good time for shoreline anglers, especially targeting cutthroat trout.

Top Fishing Spots on Bear Lake

✅ Cisco Beach (Utah side):

◉ Named for the famous Bonneville Cisco.

◉ Great for shore fishing and early winter ice fishing.

◉ Deeper water close to shore makes it ideal for whitefish and trout.

✅ North Beach State Park (Idaho side):

◉ Calm, shallow areas perfect for beginners and families.

◉ Good for perch and occasional trout.

✅ East Side Access Points:

◉ Known for deeper water and rocky terrain.

◉ Ideal for serious anglers targeting lake trout.

✅ Rainbow Cove:

◉ Accessible by boat or from the shore via trails.

◉ Deep holes near underwater ledges—excellent for mackinaw.

Ice Fishing at Bear Lake

One of the lake’s most iconic activities is ice fishing, especially during the Cisco spawning run in January. Anglers use nets and lines through the ice to catch these small fish, often in the early morning when they school near shore.

The annual Cisco Disco Festival, held near Cisco Beach, draws locals and tourists for a day of quirky fishing fun, live music, and outdoor cooking.

Popular ice fishing species:

• Bonneville Cisco
• Whitefish
• Cutthroat trout

Make sure to check ice thickness regularly and bring the appropriate gear for safety and warmth.

Fishing Licenses and Regulations

Because Bear Lake straddles two states, you’ll need a fishing license from either Utah or Idaho, but each license is valid on the entire lake. However, regulations differ slightly between the states, especially for daily catch limits and tackle use.

Key guidelines:

◉ Daily limits apply to each species (check official DWR sites).

◉ Use of multiple lines may be restricted in some areas.

◉ Cisco may be taken by dip net or angling during the open season.

◉ Ice fishing shelters must be labeled with your name and address.

Tip: Always check with the Utah Division of Wildlife Resources or the Idaho Department of Fish and Game before your trip for current rules.

Final Thoughts: Is Bear Lake Worth Fishing?

Absolutely. Bear Lake offers a rare blend of scenic beauty, uncrowded waters, and unique species that make it stand out among western U.S. fishing destinations. Whether you're on a quiet solo retreat, a weekend adventure with friends, or a family ice fishing trip, Bear Lake fishing is both rewarding and memorable.

From its endemic Cisco to its trophy-sized trout, Bear Lake is not just another fishing hole—it’s an experience steeped in nature, tradition, and quiet thrill.